ITALY: State blasted on plan to fingerprint Roma children

[ROME, 26 June 2008] - A proposal by Italy's interior minister to fingerprint Roma children as part of a crackdown on crime sparked concern has sparked concern that it is racist and would treat them like criminals.

Roma people, known in Italy as "nomads", get the blame for much of the crime which Silvio Berlusconi's new government pins on illegal immigrants. About half of the Roma come from abroad, mostly from eastern European countries such as Romania.

With reports that the estimate of 160,000 Roma in Italy may be short by 100,000, Interior Minister Roberto Maroni plans a census of their camps -- squalid shanties with poor sanitation, apart from a few model camps set up by local authorities.

Maroni, who is from the anti-immigrant Northern League party, says a census would help "guarantee that those who have the right to stay can live in decent conditions and to let us send home those who don't have the right to stay in Italy".

He told parliament late on Wednesday the census would involve fingerprinting everyone in the camps -- "children too, to avoid phenomena like begging".

Some immigrants seeking residency are fingerprinted already, but not usually children or European Union citizens.

"It will not be an ethnic register but will provide further guarantees for their rights," Maroni said. He added that police doing the census would be accompanied to Roma camps by the Italian Red Cross to give further guarantees.

An unscientific television poll suggested the measure would be popular with the public, with just over 80 percent in favour. The conservative mayor of Milan also welcomed the idea.

But deputy Rosy Bindi -- family minister in the centre-left government that collapsed in January -- said it would "treat Roma children as if they were hardened criminals".

"As much as he denies it, this would really be an ethnic register and is frankly unacceptable," she said.

Maroni's anti-crime bill, now in parliament, has measures seen as targeting the Roma, such as making it an offence punishable by prison to force children into begging.

The minister also wants illegal immigration made an offence punishable by prison, speedier expulsions and heavier prison sentences for illegal immigrants committing other crimes.

Berlusconi's conservative government has created "special commissioners" for what it calls the Roma "emergency". It has also met ministers from Romania to overcome concerns that its people could be unfairly targeted by the immigrant crackdown.

More than 500,000 Romanians are estimated to live in Italy and Bucharest fears they could all suffer from discrimination.

One Italian Jewish community leader, Amoz Luzzarto, said the fingerprinting proposal was another sign of "racism latent in Italian culture". He recalled as a child being "tagged as a Jew not to be trusted" and said Italy had "lost its memory".

"Taking the fingerprints of children from a certain ethnic group means treating them like congenital thieves," he told one paper. "This is clearly an unacceptable and racist initiative."

[Source: Reuters]

Further information


Association: Reuters


Please note that these reports are hosted by CRIN as a resource for Child Rights campaigners, researchers and other interested parties. Unless otherwise stated, they are not the work of CRIN and their inclusion in our database does not necessarily signify endorsement or agreement with their content by CRIN.