The week in children's rights - 1502

Child Rights Information Network logo
19 October 2016 subscribe | subscribe | submit information
  • CRINmail 1502

    In this issue:

    Latest news and reports
    - Refugees
    - Juvenile justice
    - Discrimination
    - Sale of children
    - Food security and stunting

    Upcoming events
    Employment

    LATEST NEWS AND REPORTS

    Refugees

    The first unaccompanied refugee children from the ‘Jungle’ refugee camp in Calais have arrived in the United Kingdom ahead of the demolition of the settlement by French authorities. The first group of children to arrive under the Dubs amendment were immediately set upon by the press, with Conservative MP David Davies taking to Twitter to claim that they did not look young enough to be brought into the UK. The MP for Monmouth called for medical tests to prove their age, but his comments were quickly condemned by medical professionals, social workers and many members of the public as unethical and potentially harmful to the young people being reunited with family in the UK. While the House of Lords called for 3,000 unaccompanied child refugees to be allowed to enter the UK, Home Secretary Amber Rudd has suggested that plans are only in place to accommodate 100. This huge disparity is raising fears over where the rest will go and how many will resort to paying smugglers to cross the border illegally. French authorities say they plan to destroy the Calais camp within days, and it as yet unclear how refugee children will be accounted for and protected.
     

    Juvenile justice

    Hundreds of children and adults under the care or supervision of the National Service of Minors (SENAME) in Chile have died in the last 11 years, with previous figures giving a far lower estimate than the true number of deaths. The latest report from SENAME states that 1313 people died in custody from 2005 to 2016, 865 of whom were children who had been placed in group homes, detention centres or remained with their families under State supervision. A judicial inquiry is now underway into the deaths and there are calls for President Bachelet to promote reform of the system, especially because the officially recorded number of deaths rose so sharply from 300 when last reported, to almost 900 in the latest figures presented in court. Representatives of UNICEF have said juvenile justice issues in Chile "are invisible" with the country’s budget only including a three percent rise in funding for SENAME next year and parliamentarians within the country have labelled the crisis the most serious violation of human rights since the reestablishment of democracy.

    Several prominent human rights groups have declared that ongoing detention of children under the Jammu and Kashmir Public Safety Act (PSA) in India violates international standards on due process and should end immediately. The International Commission of Jurists, Amnesty International India and Human Rights Watch issued a joint statement noting that detention under the PSA had increased significantly during recent weeks. Children are among those being targeted with administrative detention, though the PSA has not allowed this since it was amended in 2012. The increase in detention comes after months of unrest and follows the use of pellet guns and teargas by security forces to disperse crowds. Clashes between demonstrators and police began in July, after the killing of a local militant group’s young leader, and most of the region's schools have been closed since then due to the violence. Some children have begun to move from the Kashmir valley to areas less affected by the unrest, determined to carry on their education at any cost.

    A young woman in Iran facing execution for allegedly killing her husband is having her sentence challenged by the country’s public defender. Zeinab Sokian’s case received widespread international attention last week, and the public defender’s office has stepped in to address concerns about her confession, and evidence which backs up claims that she did not commit the murder of her husband when she was 17. The public defender’s office has also stated that they have not been in contact with Zeinab since judicial authorities announced that her execution had been scheduled for 3 October. According to the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights and the Convention on the Rights of the Child, it is illegal to execute someone for crimes committed under the age of 18. Iran is party to both treaties but still sentences juveniles to death, giving judges discretion as to whether to impose the death penalty for offences committed by children as young as eight.

    France has become the latest country to ban life imprisonment for children thanks to an amendment to the 1945 ordinance on child offenders. The law previously allowed those aged 16 or older to be sentenced as adults for certain crimes, meaning that under-18s found guilty of repeatedly committing the same offence, or of carrying out a crime with aggravating factors could be sentenced to life in prison. Despite the existence of the penalty in law it has very rarely been implemented, with only two known cases in the last 25 years. One of these sentences was subsequently overturned, leaving only one person currently serving a life sentence in France for a crime committed while under the age of 18. The change moves France off the list of States allowing inhuman sentencing of children, leaving the United Kingdom as the only country in the European Union to still allow such penalties.

     

    Discrimination

    Police in China have detained 75 people in connection with a widespread network that illegally determined the gender of unborn children. The illegal service - aimed at expectant parents wanting male children - smuggled fetal blood samples to Hong Kong for gender testing, according to officials. It operated across much of China and brought in a total of $30m (£25m). Despite decades of campaigning, Chinese families, particularly in rural areas, continue to prize boys above girls. At least 300 people were reportedly involved in the illegal service, demonstrating the scale of the demand for the tests in the country. China ended its one-child policy last year, marking the end of a policy which was seen as contributing to the country’s skewed gender balance. However, Chinese population officials this week warned that the imbalance, 113 boys for every 100 girls, would remain for years to come despite the end of the one-child era.

    At least half of the world's 65 million school-age children with disabilities are missing classes because not enough money is being budgeted for their needs. Stigma and misinformation surrounding disability as well as a lack of data on the numbers of disabled children contributed to the problem. "Children with disabilities are constantly left at the very back of the queue, and the impact on both individuals and economies can be disastrous," Julia McGeown of Handicap International said in a statement. The report by the International Disability and Development Consortium said the exclusion of children with disabilities was a major obstacle to meeting the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs), which aim to ensure inclusive and equitable quality education for all by 2030. The new report urges governments to provide facilities for the education of disabled children within the mainstream system.

    In the United States, Barack Obama signed into law a new Bill creating a Commission on Native Children, tasked with identifying and finding solutions to problems facing Native American youths. The Bill, introduced by Senator Heidi Heitkamp, is intended to determine where federal resources are going and how they can be better deployed, with the 11-member commission expected to produce a report in three years. In late September, the Obama administration announced that it agreed to pay more than $492 million to 17 Native American tribes as a result of lawsuits accusing the federal government of mismanaging natural resources and other tribal assets, while earlier this month, the US Court of Appeals ruled against two Native American tribes allowing construction on the Dakota Access Pipeline to move forward.

     

    Sale of children


    The Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe has rejected a draft recommendation on children's rights and surrogacy, following heated discussions. The recommendation proposed drawing up European guidelines to safeguard children's rights in surrogacy arrangements and work with the Hague Conference on International Private Law in their work on this issue. It condemned for-profit surrogacy but took no position on altruistic surrogacy (though the line separating the two is blurred). However, proposed amendments rejected surrogacy in all its forms. Fiercely divided on the issue, some voiced concerns about the potential implications for the rights of women and reducing a child to a contract. Others stated that surrogacy is a fact and it is not feasible to just vote children who have been born in this way out of existence, arguing that it is better to regulate the practice in accordance with the best interests of the child than to try to impose an unrealistic ban.

    Read CRIN’s special edition Children in Court CRINmail on surrogacy for more information on this topic.

    The chief executive of a website known for sexually oriented advertisements has been arrested and charged with conspiracy and pimping a minor after raids on the company’s headquarters in Dallas, United States. The website, Backpage.com, which describes itself as the second-largest online classified advertising service in the country, has faced accusations in various jurisdictions of sex trafficking, but this is the first time criminal charges have been brought against its staff based on these claims. Carl Ferrer, 55, the chief executive, will face an extradition hearing in Texas that could return him to California to face charges. Interviews with children filed for the case revealed they took out advertisements on Backpage.com after they were forced into prostitution. A 15-year-old girl said she was a forced into prostitution when she was 13, and that Backpage “profits off of women and men,” whether they earn money or are forced into it. A congressional investigation this year found that the website masked the fact that it advertised sex acts with minors as adult classifieds by editing the details.


    Food security and stunting

    Five in six children under two years old in developing countries are undernourished and at risk of irreversible physical and mental harm, according to a report by UNICEF. The findings reveal that detrimental nutritional practices such as the delayed introduction of solid foods and poor food variety are widespread, depriving many infants of the energy and nutrients needed for proper physical and cognitive development. Stunting rates are highest in South Asia and sub-Saharan Africa, but studies also show that junk foods low in micronutrients and protein are becoming increasingly common in children’s diets in rich and poor countries alike. The report was published ahead of World Food Day on 16 October, and highlighted that improvements to the quantity and quality of nutrition for young children could save 100,000 lives a year.

    A UN-backed study has revealed that childhood hunger is costing Chad almost $1 billion per year - 9.5 percent of its gross domestic product (GDP) - in costs related to health, education and lower productivity in adult life. More than half of Chad’s adults suffered from stunting as children, preventing them from achieving their full potential at the country’s expense, according to the Cost of Hunger in Africa report on Chad, the ninth in a series of reports looking at the consequences of child undernutrition in the continent which have concluded that African economies are losing between 1.9 and 16 percent of their GDP as a result of child undernutrition. The report calls for increased investment in nutrition with special attention to the early stages of life, and it is hoped that drawing attention to the steep cost of hunger in Chad will lead to more aggressive measures to eliminate stunting.

    In India, the Bombay High Court has expressed concern over state government apathy in addressing the malnutrition problems faced by tribal communities in Maharashtra, observing that tribal peoples have been neglected since the British era and continue to suffer disproportionately from undernourishment. The observations were made during a series of public interest litigations highlighting the deaths of tribal children due to malnutrition and the poor quality of food provided by the government as part of ‘take-home rations’ schemes. The Court expressed dissatisfaction at the government’s submissions, finding that there has been no progress in living standards for tribal communities and that the budgetary allocations for tribal welfare are insufficient, despite claims that the number of child deaths has fallen. The Court has given the government a final chance to file an affidavit outlining its budgetary and policy proposals, reserving the matter for a further hearing in late October.

    Back to top

    UPCOMING EVENTS

     

    Separated children: Separated children in judicial proceedings - exploring the use and application of European and international mechanisms for the protection of vulnerable and separated children’s rights
    Organisation: Child Circle; AIRE Centre; University College Cork; and ROSA
    Dates: 27-28 October 2016
    Location: Brussels, Belgium

    Violence: 19 Days of Activism For the Prevention of Violence Against Children and Youth
    Organisation: Women's World Summit Foundation
    Dates: 1-19 November 2016
    Location: Global

    Education: Master of Advanced Studies in Children’s Rights
    Application deadline: 1 November 2016
    Dates: February 2017-November 2018
    Location: Sion, Switzerland

    Education in Emergencies
    Organisation: HREA
    Dates: 2 November-13 December 2016
    Location: online (e-learning course)

    Children in War and Armed Conflicts
    Organisation: HREA
    Dates: 2 November-13 December 2016
    Location: online (e-learning course)

    Child in the City Conference
    Organisation: Child in the City Foundation
    Dates: 7-9 November
    Location: Ghent, Belgium

    Child care: Children's Rights in Alternative Care - Walk the Talk!
    Organisation: SOS Children’s Villages
    Dates: 8-9 November 2016
    Location: Paris, France

    Business and Human Rights: 2016 UN Forum
    Organisation: Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights
    Dates: 14-16 November 2016
    Location: Geneva, Switzerland

    Right to work: Eliminating child labour and promoting decent work in agriculture
    Organisation: The International Training Centre of the ILO (ITCILO)
    Dates: 14-18 November 2016
    Location: Turin, Italy

    Child labour: Developing skills and livelihood training programmes for older children
    Organisation: ITCILO
    Dates: 21-25 November 2016
    Location: Turin, Italy

    Education: International Children’s Rights
    Organisation: Leiden University
    Application deadline: 1 April 2017 (non-EU) / 15 June 2017 (EU students)
    Dates: September 2017 - Summer 2018
    Location: Leiden, The Netherlands

    International Conference on Shared Parenting
    Organisations: The National Parents Organization & the International Council on Shared Parenting
    Dates: 29-31 May 2017
    Location: Boston, United States

    Back to top

     

    EMPLOYMENT


    Orchid Project: Chief Operating Officer
    Application deadline: Rolling
    Location: London, United Kingdom

    Keeping children safe: Senior Child Safeguarding Advisor
    Application deadline: 23 October 2016
    Location: London, United Kingdom

    Council of Europe: Programme Advisor
    Application deadline: 26 October 2016
    Location: Strasbourg, France

    Save the Children Sweden: Regional advisor
    Application deadline: 4 November 2016
    Location: Asia (TBD)

    Center for Reproductive Rights: Global Advocacy Adviser
    Application deadline: 19 November 2016
    Location: Geneva, Switzerland

    Oak Institute: Fellowship in film/photography and human rights
    Application deadline: 2 December 2016
    Location: Maine, United States

    Back to top

     

    THE LAST WORD

    Involving children in discussions about politics is vital to their development as socially conscious individuals, but can parents introduce their children to these debates when the content is violent, discriminatory or just foul-mouthed? While the election in the United States has put these issues in the spotlight, the question also applies to the Philippines, where the President has declared dead children as “collateral damage” in his war on drugs, and to war torn countries like Yemen and Syria, where disregard for human life has become the hallmark of both conflicts.

    Politicians and newsreaders will aim their versions of current events towards adults, but parents, teachers and other adults in contact with children may need to present the news to young people in a different way. Most importantly, when children ask about difficult topics, try to be honest, answer their questions and pay attention to their emotional reaction. For more on discussing difficult topics with children, read the advice offered by the Norwegian Ombudsman for Children.

    Back to top

    © Child Rights International Network 2019 ~ http://crin.org

    The CRINmail is an electronic mailing list of the Child Rights International Network (CRIN). CRIN does not accredit, validate or substantiate any information posted by members to the CRINmail. The validity and accuracy of any information is the responsibility of the originator. To subscribe, unsubscribe or view list archives, visit http://crin.org/crinmail.